3d Retreat Forums
3d Retreat Forums
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 3d Retreat
 General Discussion
 Radeon 9000 vs a Geforce 3/4 ?
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Oblivion
Sergeant

NJ
196 Posts

Posted - 11/24/2002 :  6:38:15 PM  Show Profile  Visit Oblivion's Homepage  Reply with Quote
Hey guys,

Was hoping for some tips on what to buy. Winter break is coming soon so i figured id upgrade my system alittle bit to enjoy some games again.

my current system specs.
pentium 3 - 933mhz
256mb
20gb hard drive
tnt2 16mb


I already bough 768mbs of Ram for it, and am now aiming towards a video card... now what should I get? A radeon 9000? they got for about 100 on sites found thru pricewatch.com or a Geforce3/4? which vary...

i dont really wanna go over 100$, so what do you suggest? is the radeon 9000 a good buy since i only have a 933mhz?

as always, thanks for your suggestions

Peter "Oblivion" Sienkiewicz
oblivion@3dretreat.com

CR6
Administrator

Canada
2548 Posts

Posted - 11/25/2002 :  12:22:36 AM  Show Profile  Visit CR6's Homepage  Reply with Quote
Yo Oblivion

Couple things you have to know:

1) A Radeon 9000 is NOT a DirectX 9 level card. The naming is misleading. It is actually the SAME GPU as the Radeon 8500 but made on a smaller die (.15 micron) and has one less pipeline (or whatever its called) so it is actually SLOWER than a Radeon 8500. It compares to the Radeon 8500LE.

2) If you get a GeForce 4 card, do NOT get a GeForce 4 MX cards (NV17), since they are actually DirectX 7 level cards like the GeForce 2!! nVidia pulled a fast one naming them too.

3) The GeForce 3 (NV20) and GeForce 4 Ti series (NV25) are both DirectX 8 cards. The best value these days is a GeForce 4 Ti 4200, but it may be out of your price range. I personally would suggest looking for a GF 3 Ti 500 since it is a good match for your CPU, and runs all current DX8 games great! (I still run a GF3 (non-Titanium) on a P4 1.7 and I get good fps in most of my games with the new drivers)

The other reason I'd get an nVidia card is that most developers these days are using them to create games. ATI will likely be used more in the future as they are catching up, but games made with the current ATI cards won't show up for another year or so.

Your next upgrade should be your CPU/mobo, as any of the newest vid cards will actually be limited by your CPU, and not run as fast as their potential.

4) All DirectX 9 cards are out of your price range, but if you do want one, the Radeon 9500 (non-pro version) is a good deal.

So in summary:
DirectX 7 level
- GeForce 2, GeForce 4 MX, Radeon 7500

DirectX 8 level
- GeForce 3 & 4 Ti, Radeon 8500, 9000

DirectX 9
- GeForce FX, Radeon 9500 & 9700

My recommendation for your around your price range: GF 3 Ti 500
Go to Top of Page

Oblivion
Sergeant

NJ
196 Posts

Posted - 11/25/2002 :  11:25:52 AM  Show Profile  Visit Oblivion's Homepage  Reply with Quote
thanks for your suggestion

i was looking up some stuff on the ti 500 and i think ill be getting that one.. just one thing tho

I have a ATI tv tuner card and it seems to work really crappy with nVidia chips.. so im thinking whether I should sacrifice alittle bit of frame rate and get the Radeon just to get the stupid card working, because i dont want to buy a new one.

Peter "Oblivion" Sienkiewicz
oblivion@3dretreat.com
Go to Top of Page

CShock
Sergeant

My house, you?
100 Posts

Posted - 11/27/2002 :  05:20:02 AM  Show Profile  Visit CShock's Homepage  Send CShock an AOL message  Send CShock an ICQ Message  Reply with Quote
I have a RADEON 9700 PRO, Stock from ATi.. I really really love it, nvidia is just really gone down hill, while ATi is going up. Want more info? go to rage3d.com
Go to Top of Page

CR6
Administrator

Canada
2548 Posts

Posted - 11/27/2002 :  11:34:19 PM  Show Profile  Visit CR6's Homepage  Reply with Quote
>I have a ATI tv tuner card and it seems to work really crappy with nVidia chips

Hmm ... which one do you have? Did it work ok with a previous ATI card? Because there's no guarantee it will work well with a new ATI card either (ATI doesn't have the greatest support for legacy products). It could be a driver issue (especially if you're running Win2K or WinXP), or check for IRQ conflicts etc.

In any case, I am currently running both a GF3 (original) and a Radeon 7200. I like ATI manufactured Radeons (i.e. NOT made by a 3rd party) for their superior 2D (the GF3/4 2D really varies depending on the manufacturer - some of the GF4's are quite poor). ATI also has better DVD playback support in hardware.

However, although ATI's drivers are improving, they still have substantial problems compared to nVidia's more mature drivers. This may or may not be a problem depending on what games you play. Eg. Unreal 2003 had probs with the Radeon 9700 before a recent driver fix, while it runs fine on GF4's. For the games I play, there are less visual glitches on the GeForce.

Oblivion ... if you want to get an ATI card and you can save up to another $100 and wait a bit, consider getting the new Radeon 9500 Pro. It has DirectX 9 support and will last longer (eg. when you upgrade your machine) than a Radeon 9000. It's also a better deal than a GeForce 4 Ti 4200/4600 because it has more features and may run just as fast in some cases as a Radeon 9700. This article says it will be selling at a price point of $200!
http://beyond3d.com/reviews/ati/radeon9500pro/index.php?p=12#conclusion

Another review:
http://firingsquad.gamers.com/hardware/9500pro/default.asp

Hmm ... I might get one myself ;-)
Go to Top of Page

izzy
Private

USA
22 Posts

Posted - 12/12/2002 :  11:13:08 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
i agree with c shock nvidia just sux the only one that they have thats any good is the new nforce but you need at least 1.6ghz to even run it but stick with ati theve always done me good.
Go to Top of Page

CR6
Administrator

Canada
2548 Posts

Posted - 12/12/2002 :  12:00:34 PM  Show Profile  Visit CR6's Homepage  Reply with Quote
Hehe, just bought an ATI Radeon 9500 Pro yesterday. I think it's the best bang for your buck at US$200 for a DirectX 9 level card. I also wanted better hardware DVD support and 2D quality for my main rig which the GF cards don't have. Just need time to install and tinker around with it ...

However, I think at US$100, for a DX8 level card, a GF3 is a better buy than an ATI Radeon 8500LE or 9000. I have an original GF3 card and have never had any problems with it. Remember a lot of Xbox games that will be ported to the PC are optimized for the GF3.
Go to Top of Page

xte_dea
Private

USA
9 Posts

Posted - 12/14/2002 :  09:39:50 AM  Show Profile  Visit xte_dea's Homepage  Send xte_dea an AOL message  Send xte_dea a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
Get the G Force 3, its a better buy and a more reliable card

- - hmmm, doesn't that killin taste good? - -
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
3d Retreat Forums © 2000-2004 3d Retreat Network Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.14 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000